As the 2026 NFL season approaches, fans of the New Orleans Saints are eagerly anticipating the return of quarterback Derek Carr. After announcing his retirement in 2023 due to a series of injuries, Carr has recently expressed interest in coming out of retirement to play for the Saints. While this news may have some fans excited, it’s important to consider whether or not Carr is truly the solution for the team.
First and foremost, it’s important to acknowledge Carr’s talent and accomplishments during his time in the NFL. He was a standout quarterback for the Oakland Raiders, leading them to several playoff appearances and even earning a Pro Bowl nod in 2020. However, it’s been three years since Carr last played in the league and it’s uncertain how his body and skills have held up during that time.
Injuries have plagued Carr throughout his career, with his most recent retirement being a result of a serious knee injury. While he may have had time to heal and recover, it’s important to consider the toll that multiple injuries can have on a player’s body. At 35 years old, Carr may not have the same physical abilities and durability that he once had. This could greatly impact his performance on the field and potentially put him at risk for further injuries.
Another factor to consider is the current state of the New Orleans Saints. While they have been a dominant team in recent years, they are currently in a rebuilding phase. Their longtime quarterback Drew Brees has retired and the team is facing a number of salary cap issues. Bringing in a veteran quarterback like Carr may not be the best decision for the team’s long-term success. It could also hinder the development of younger quarterbacks on the roster who could potentially be the future of the franchise.
Additionally, there are other options available for the Saints at the quarterback position. The team has already signed Jameis Winston and Taysom Hill, both of whom have shown promise and potential. It’s possible that one of these quarterbacks could step up and lead the team to success in the upcoming season. Bringing in Carr could potentially disrupt the chemistry and dynamic of the team, causing more harm than good.
Furthermore, the NFL is constantly evolving and changing. The game is becoming faster and more physically demanding, and it’s uncertain if Carr’s playing style will still be effective in today’s league. As a pocket passer, he may struggle to keep up with the speed and athleticism of younger players. This could greatly impact his performance and the success of the team.
In conclusion, while it may be exciting to think about Derek Carr returning to the NFL and playing for the New Orleans Saints, there are many factors that need to be considered. His past injuries, age, and the current state of the team all raise valid concerns about whether or not he is truly the solution for the Saints. It’s important for the team to carefully evaluate their options and make the best decision for the future of the franchise. Only time will tell if Derek Carr will be the answer for the Saints, but for now, it’s best to approach this news with cautious optimism.
