What happens when a former UFC champion casually weighs in on one of MMA’s most sacred “What if?” debates? You get chaos, confusion, and a fanbase ready to storm the comment section with pitchforks. That’s exactly what unfolded after Robert Whittaker’s recent appearance on his MMArcade Podcast, where he tackled the unthinkable: Prime Georges St-Pierre.
For years, fans have debated who would come out on top in a hypothetical matchup between current lightweight contender Islam Makhachev and former welterweight and middleweight champion Georges St-Pierre. Both fighters have dominated their respective divisions and have a similar fighting style, making it a dream matchup for many MMA enthusiasts.
But when Whittaker, who is currently the number one contender in the middleweight division, gave his take on the potential fight, it caused quite a stir among fans and the MMA community.
Whittaker, who is known for his no-nonsense approach and brutal honesty, didn’t hold back when discussing the matchup. He stated that he believes Makhachev would come out on top against Prime St-Pierre, citing his youth, size, and grappling skills as the deciding factors.
This bold take from Whittaker has left fans divided, with some agreeing with his assessment and others vehemently disagreeing. But one thing is for sure, it has sparked a heated debate and has fans eagerly waiting for a response from St-Pierre himself.
The debate between Makhachev and Prime St-Pierre is not a new one. Many have tried to analyze and break down the potential fight, but it has always remained a hypothetical scenario. However, with Whittaker’s comments, it has become a hot topic once again, and fans are eager to see how it unfolds.
But why is this particular matchup so intriguing? Well, for starters, both fighters have a similar fighting style. They are both known for their dominant grappling skills and have a high level of control on the ground. This makes it a fascinating matchup, as it would be a battle of two elite grapplers.
Moreover, both fighters have had impressive careers in the UFC. St-Pierre is widely considered one of the greatest fighters of all time, with a record of 26 wins and only two losses in his professional MMA career. On the other hand, Makhachev is currently on a seven-fight win streak and has been dominating his opponents in the lightweight division.
But what makes Whittaker’s take on the matchup even more interesting is the fact that he is a former opponent of St-Pierre. The two faced off in a highly anticipated fight at UFC 217 in 2017, where St-Pierre came out of retirement to challenge for the middleweight title. St-Pierre went on to win the fight via submission in the third round, but Whittaker has always maintained that he would love to have a rematch with the legend.
So, it’s safe to say that Whittaker’s opinion on the potential matchup holds some weight. He has been in the octagon with St-Pierre and knows firsthand the level of skill and dominance he possesses. And if he believes that Makhachev would come out on top, it’s definitely something worth considering.
But of course, not everyone agrees with Whittaker’s take. Many fans and experts believe that Prime St-Pierre would still be able to outclass Makhachev, even at this stage in his career. They argue that St-Pierre’s experience and fight IQ would be enough to overcome Makhachev’s youth and size advantage.
However, one thing is for sure, if this fight were to ever happen, it would be a dream matchup for MMA fans. It would be a clash of two elite fighters, both in their prime, and it’s hard to predict who would come out on top.
But for now, it remains a hypothetical scenario, and fans can only speculate and debate on the outcome. Whittaker’s bold take has certainly added fuel to the fire and has fans eagerly waiting for a response from St-Pierre.
In the end, it’s all just a matter of opinion. Whittaker has given his take on the potential matchup, and it has caused quite a stir among fans. But at the end of the day, it’s all just speculation, and we may never know who would come out on top in a fight between Makhachev and Prime St-Pierre.
